The following are excerpts on human rights issues of Southern Mongolia from the United States Congressional Executive Commission on China Annual Report 2019 released on November 18, 2019:
[page 119-122]
Grassland Protests in Inner
Mongolia
During this reporting year, authorities detained Mongol herders who protested or petitioned the government over the loss of traditional grazing lands. As in past reporting years,22 authorities detained some of the Mongol herders who peacefully protested.23 Representative examples of protests and petitioning by Mongol herders included the following:
- In April 2019, authorities administratively detained three Mongol herders who had traveled to Hohhot municipality, Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region (IMAR), to petition authorities over access to grazing lands.24 Authorities escorted herders Haaserdun, Tegshibayla, and Oobuuren back to their hometown in Zaruud Banner, Tongliao municipality, IMAR, and ordered them to serve eight days’ administrative detention for “picking quarrels and provoking trouble.” 25
- On April 22, 2019, more than 100 Mongol herders in Urad (Wulate) Middle Banner, Bayannur (Bayannao’er) municipality, IMAR, protested in front of local government offices to demand a meeting with IMAR chairwoman Bu Xiaolin, who was visiting the area.26 Authorities detained around a dozen herders, including Bai Xiurong and Altanbagan, each of whom security personnel ordered to serve 14 days’ administrative detention for unknown charges.27 On the evening of April 22 and the early morning of April 23, some of the herders protested in front of a local government building to call for the release of Bai, Altanbagan, and other herders still detained.28
Ethnic Minority Rights
Detention of Mongol Writers
Authorities in the IMAR tried a Mongol historian on charges related to a book he wrote and detained two Mongol writers who had advocated on behalf of herders’ rights:
- Lhamjab Borjigin. On April 4, 2019, the Xilingol (Xilinguole) League Intermediate People’s Court in Xilinhot city, Xilingol League, tried 75-year-old Mongol historian Lhamjab Borjigin on the charges of “ethnic separatism,” “sabotaging national unity,” and “illegal publication and illegal distribution.”29 A Xilinhot official previously linked the first two charges to a book Borjigin self-published in 2006 about Mongols’ experiences during the Cultural Revolution.30
- O. Sechenbaatar. On April 12, 2019, security personnel in Heshigten (Keshenketeng) Banner, Chifeng municipality, detained 68-year-old Mongol writer O. Sechenbaatar on suspicion of “obstructing official business,” after he participated in a nearby protest involving more than 200 herders over government plans to restrict local herders’ access to traditional grazing lands.31 Sechenbaatar has authored numerous books and other materials on Mongolian culture, and he has hosted group discussions about Mongol herders’ concerns on the messaging service WeChat.32 On April 16, 2019, more than 100 herders protested in front of a government building in Heshigten to call for O. Sechenbaatar’s release from detention.33
- Tsogjil. On April 16, 2019, security personnel in Hohhot took into custody 40-year-old Mongol writer Tsogjil, and authorities subsequently took him back to his hometown in Heshigten Banner, and detained him on April 17 on the charge of "picking quarrels and provoking trouble.” 34 According to a U.S.-based Mongol rights organization, prior to his detention, Tsogjil had advocated for Mongols’ language and cultural rights, as well as their access to natural resources, including by hosting WeChat discussion groups.35 Tsogjil had traveled to Hohhot to submit a complaint to regional government officials regarding Mongol herders’ rights.36
Notes to Section II—Ethnic Minority Rights
1 Zhonghua Renmin
Gongheguo Minzu Quyu Zizhi Fa, [PRC
Regional Ethnic Autonomy Law],
passed May 31, 1984, effective
October 1, 1984, amended February
28, 2001. For protections related to
languages, religious beliefs, and
customs, see Articles 10, 11, 21,
36, 37, 47, 49, and53.
2 International Covenant
on Civil and Political Rights,
adopted by UN General Assembly
resolution 2200A (XXI) of December
16, 1966, entry into force March 23,
1976, art. 27.
3 See, e.g., Rustem Shir,
“China’s Effort to Silence the Sound
of Uyghur,” The Diplomat, May
16, 2019; Sang Jieja, “Why Is China
So Terrified of Tibetan Language
Classes?,” La Croix International,
March 4, 2019; Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center, “SMHRIC
Statement at UN Forum on Minority
Issues 11th Session and Chinese
Delegate’s Response,” November 29,
2018.
4 See, e.g., Amnesty
International, “China: Human Rights
Violations in the Name of ‘National
Security’: Amnesty International
Submission for the UN Universal
Periodic Review, 31st Session of the
UPR Working Group, November 2018,”
March 1, 2018, 7, 11–12; Society for
Threatened Peoples, “Third Cycle,
Thirty-First Session of the UPR, UPR
Submission on China,” accessed June
11, 2019, 2–3; Human Rights Watch,
“Submission to the Universal
Periodic Review of China,” March 29,
2018.
5 Gerry Groot, “The Rise
and Rise of the United Front Work
Department under Xi,” China Brief,
Jamestown Foundation 18, no. 7,
April 24, 2018; “Zhonggong zhongyang
yinfa ‘shenhua Dang he guojia jigou
gaige fang’an’ ” [CCP Central
Committee issues “plan for deepening
reform of Party and state government
agencies’ reform agenda”], Xinhua,
March 21, 2018; CECC, 2018 Annual
Report, October 10, 2018, 137. At
the March 2018 meetings of the
National People’s Congress and the
Chinese People’s Political
Consultative Conference in Beijing
municipality (Two Sessions), the
UFWD assumed control of the
government departments overseeing
ethnic affairs (the State Ethnic
Affairs Commission) and religion
(the State Administration for
Religious Affairs).
6 Shen Guiping, “Jiang
qingchu Zhonghua wenhua, zhulao
Zhonghua minzu gongtong tiyishi—‘Shehui
Zhuyi Xueyuan Gongzuo Tiaoli’ xuexi
tihui” [Clearly explain Chinese
culture, forge a unified Chinese
consciousness – “Socialism Institute
Work Regulations” learning
experience], China Ethnicity News,
February 1, 2019.
7 Tao Wenzhao, “Zai
gongtong fanrong fazhan zhong zhulao
Zhonghua minzu gongtong tiyishi”
[Forging Chinese collective
consciousness while collectively
prospering in development],
Guangming Daily, January 5,
2018.
8 Hao Shiyuan, “Zhulao
Zhonghua minzu gongtong ti yishi
bixu tuiguang guojia tongyong yuyan
wenzi” [To forge Chinese collective
consciousness the national common
language and characters must be
promoted], People’s Daily,
October 31, 2018; Shen Guiping,
“Jiang qingchu Zhonghua wenhua,
zhulao Zhonghua minzu gongtong ti
yishi—‘Shehui Zhuyi Xueyuan Gongzuo
Tiaoli’ xuexi tihui” [Clearly
explain Chinese culture, forge a
unified Chinese consciousness –
“Socialism Institute Work
Regulations” learning experience],
China Ethnicity News,
February 1, 2019.
9 Shen Guiping, “Jiang
qingchu Zhonghua wenhua, zhulao
Zhonghua minzu gongtong tiyishi—‘Shehui
Zhuyi Xueyuan Gongzuo Tiaoli’ xuexi
tihui” [Clearly explain Chinese
culture, forge a unified Chinese
consciousness – “Socialism Institute
Work Regulations” learning
experience], China Ethnicity News,
February 1, 2019.
10 State Ethnic Affairs
Commission, “Guojia minwei zhaokai
quanguo minzu xuanchuan gongzuo
huiyi Guo Weiping chuxi bing
jianghua” [SEAC holds national
ethnic propaganda work meeting, Guo
Weiping attends and delivers a
speech], March 27, 2019.
11 “You Quan: Jianchi
Dang dui zongjiao gongzuo de lingdao,
chixu tuijin woguo zongjiao
Zhongguohua” [You Quan: uphold the
Party’s leadership over religious
work, persist in advancing the
Sinicization of our country’s
religions] Xinhua, March 20,
2019. See also John Dotson,
“Propaganda Themes at the CPPCC
Stress the ‘Sinicization’ of
Religion,” China Brief,
Jamestown Foundation, April 9, 2019,
2.
12 State Council,
“Zhengfu gongzuo baogao” [Government
work report], reprinted in Xinhua,
March 16, 2019; Nectar Gan, “Beijing
Plans to Continue Tightening Grip on
Christianity and Islam as China
Pushes Ahead with the ‘Sinicisation
of Religion,’ ” South China
Morning Post, March 6, 2019.
13 See, e.g., Mimi Lau,
“Chinese Arabic School to Close as
Areas with Muslim Populations Are
Urged to Study the Xinjiang Way,”
South China Morning Post,
December 9, 2018; Sam McNeil, “Hui
Poet Fears for His People as China
‘Sinicizes’ Religion,” Associated
Press, December 28, 2018.
14 Ian Johnson, “How the
State Is Co-Opting Religion in
China,” Foreign Affairs, January 7,
2019; Chun Han Wong, “China Applies
Xinjiang’s Policing Lessons to Other
Muslim Areas,” Wall Street
Journal, December 23, 2018;
Nectar Gan, “Chinese Hui Mosque
Protest Ends after Authorities
Promise to Consult Community,”
South China Morning Post, August
15, 2018; “China’s Ningxia to ‘Learn
From’ Xinjiang’s Anti-Terror
Campaign,” Radio Free Asia,
December 3, 2018. Hui Muslims also
live in the XUAR, but reports from
the past reporting year have focused
on increased repression of Hui
communities outside of the XUAR.
See, e.g., Joanne Smith Finley, “
‘Now We Don’t Talk Anymore,’ ”
ChinaFile, Asia Society,
December 28, 2018.
15 Ji Yuqiao, “Ningxia
Learns From Xinjiang How to Fight
Terrorism,” Global Times,
November 27, 2018; Deng Zhihua,
“Ningxia dangwei zhengfa wei deng
bumen fu Xinjiang kaocha duijie
fankong weiwen gongzuo” [Ningxia
political-legal committee department
travels to Xinjiang to inspect
counterterrorism and stability
maintenance work], Ningxia Daily,
November 27, 2018. See also “China’s
Ningxia to ‘Learn From’ Xinjiang’s
Anti-Terror Campaign,” Radio Free
Asia, December 3, 2018; Sophia
Yan, “Fears China’s Internment Camps
Could Spread as Area Home to Muslim
Minority Signs ‘Anti-Terror’ Deal,”
Telegraph, November 29, 2018.
Ethnic Minority Rights
16 Sophia Yan, “Fears
China’s Internment Camps Could
Spread as Area Home to Muslim
Minority Signs ‘Anti-Terror’ Deal,”
Telegraph, November 29, 2018.
See also David R. Stroup, “The
Xinjiang Model of Ethnic Politics
and the Daily Practice of
Ethnicity,” China at the
Crossroads (blog), December 19,
2018.
17 “Gansu Linxia yi
qingzhensi zao qiangchai duo ren bei
ju” [A mosque in Linxia, Gansu, is
demolished, many people are
detained], Radio Free Asia,
April 12, 2019; William Yang,
“Zhongguo xu tui Yisilan Hanhua
Gansu qingzhensi zao ‘mieding’ ”
[China continues Hanification of
Islam, Gansu mosque “extinguished”],
Deutsche Welle, April 12,
2019; Bai Shengyi, “Gansu yi
qingzhensi gang jiancheng jiu zao
qiangchai Musilin laoren tang de
tongku” [Mosque in Gansu demolished
just after being built, elderly
Muslims lie on the ground and weep],
Bitter Winter, April 12,
2019.
18 Liwei Wu, “Love Allah,
Love China,” Foreign Policy, March
25, 2019; Meng Yihua, “Three Hui
Mosques Raided in China’s Yunnan
Province,” Muslim News,
January 25, 2019.
19 Zhao Yusha, “Gansu
Shuts Down Arabic School over
Regulations,” Global Times,
December 4, 2018; Mimi Lau, “Chinese
Arabic School to Close as Areas with
Muslim Populations Are Urged to
Study the Xinjiang Way,” South
China Morning Post, December 9,
2018; Chun Han Wong, “China Applies
Xinjiang’s Policing Lessons to Other
Muslim Areas,” Wall Street
Journal, December 23, 2018.
20 James Palmer, “China’s
Muslims Brace for Attacks,” Foreign
Policy, January 5, 2019; Liu Caiyu,
“Gansu Removes 4 Halal-Linked
Standards to Curb Religious
Extremism,” Global Times,
December 17, 2018; “China:
‘Arabic-Sounding’ River Renamed to
Curb Islamic Influence,” Al
Jazeera, October 2, 2018; Liwei
Wu, “Love Allah, Love China,”
Foreign Policy, March 25, 2019.
See also Liu Caiyu, “Islamic
Communities Urged to Uphold
Sinicization, Improve Political
Stance,” Global Times,
January 6, 2019; Nectar Gan,
“Beijing Plans to Continue
Tightening Grip on Christianity and
Islam as China Pushes Ahead with the
‘Sinicisation of Religion,’ ”
South China Morning Post, March
6, 2019; Sam McNeil, “Hui Poet Fears
for His People as China ‘Sinicizes’
Religion,” Associated Press,
December 28, 2018.
21 Huizhong Wu, “Sign of
the Times: China’s Capital Orders
Arabic, Muslim Symbols Taken Down,”
Reuters, July 31, 2019.
22 See, e.g., CECC, 2018
Annual Report, October 10,
2018, 139; CECC, 2017 Annual
Report, October 5 2017, 148–49.
23 See, e.g., “Chinese
Police Hold Another Ethnic Mongolian
Writer over Protest,” Radio Free
Asia, April 16, 2019; Southern
Mongolian Human Rights Information
Center, “Two More WeChat Group
Administrators Detained,” April 26,
2019.
24 “Chinese Police Hold
Another Ethnic Mongolian Writer over
Protest,” Radio Free Asia,
April 16, 2019; “Nei menggu duo wei
mumin shangfang bei juliu Neimeng
xuexiao jinggao bu de wangyi lingdao
ren” [Many herder petitioners
detained in Inner Mongolia, Inner
Mongolian school warned against
discussing leaders], Radio Free
Asia, April 8, 2019.
25 “Chinese Police Hold
Another Ethnic Mongolian Writer over
Protest,” Radio Free Asia,
April 16, 2019; “Nei menggu duo wei
mumin shangfang bei juliu Neimeng
xuexiao jinggao bu de wangyi lingdao
ren” [Many herder petitioners
detained in Inner Mongolia, Inner
Mongolian school warned against
discussing leaders], Radio Free
Asia, April 8, 2019.
26 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Two More WeChat Group
Administrators Detained,” April 26,
2019; “Two More Ethnic Mongolians
Jailed in China, WeChat Groups
Deleted,” Radio Free Asia,
April 26, 2019.
27 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Two More WeChat Group
Administrators Detained,” April 26,
2019; “Two More Ethnic Mongolians
Jailed in China, WeChat Groups
Deleted,” Radio Free Asia,
April 26, 2019.
28 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Two More WeChat Group
Administrators Detained,” April 26,
2019; “Two More Ethnic Mongolians
Jailed in China, WeChat Groups
Deleted,” Radio Free Asia,
April 26, 2019.
29 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Writer Tried behind Closed Doors as
‘National Separatist,’ Pending
Sentence,” April 11, 2019; “China
Tries Ethnic Mongolian Historian for
Genocide Book, in Secret,” Radio
Free Asia, April 12, 2019. For
more information on Lhamjab Borjigin,
see the Commission’s Political
Prisoner Database record 2019–00105.
30 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Southern Mongolian Writer Faces
Charges of ‘National Separatism’ and
‘Sabotaging National Unity,’ ” July
23, 2018; “Neimeng qi xun zuojia jiu
zuo fanyi Hanzi zao qingsuan dangju
ni yi fenlie zui qisu” [Inner
Mongolian writer in his seventies
faces criticism for older Chinese
translation work, authorities plan
to indict him for separatism],
Radio Free Asia, July 23, 2018;
“China Holds Ethnic Mongolian
Historian Who Wrote ‘Genocide’
Book,” Radio Free Asia, July
23, 2018.
31 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Writer Placed under Criminal
Detention for Defending Herders’
Rights,” April 16, 2019; “Chinese
Police Hold Another Ethnic Mongolian
Writer over Protest,” Radio Free
Asia, April 16, 2019.
32 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Writer Placed under Criminal
Detention for Defending Herders’
Rights,” April 16, 2019; “Chinese
Police Hold Another Ethnic Mongolian
Writer over Protest,” Radio Free
Asia, April 16, 2019.
33 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Writer Placed under Criminal
Detention for Defending Herders’
Rights,” April 16, 2019.
34 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Activist Placed under Criminal
Detention for ‘Picking Quarrels and
Provoking Troubles,’ ” April 19,
2019; “Third Ethnic Mongolian Writer
Held in China’s Inner Mongolia,”
Radio Free Asia, April 22, 2019.
35 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Activist Placed under Criminal
Detention for ‘Picking Quarrels and
Provoking Troubles,’ ” April 19,
2019; “Third Ethnic Mongolian Writer
Held in China’s Inner Mongolia,”
Radio Free Asia, April 22, 2019.
36 Southern Mongolian
Human Rights Information Center,
“Activist Placed under Criminal
Detention for ‘Picking Quarrels and
Provoking Troubles,’ ” April 19,
2019; “Third Ethnic Mongolian Writer
Held in China’s Inner Mongolia,”
Radio Free Asia, April 22, 2019.